Andrew Sullivan's latest reply in his debate with Sam Harris is out. One statement jumps right out at me:
What you are doing here by the use of the word "lying" is imputing to the believer an insincerity you cannot know for sure.
Sullivan would never accuse someone of lying when he didn't "know for sure."
Oh wait... "[Attorney General Alberto] Gonzales is a liar..." Presumably Sullivan has developed psychic powers and is absolutely certain that Gonzales is being insincere.